A comprehensive guide to evaluating preferred shares, covering issuer creditworthiness, dividend coverage, share types, tax considerations, and interest rate sensitivity in the Canadian financial landscape.
Preferred shares occupy a middle ground between equities and fixed-income securities. They combine the potential upside of equity participation (especially in the case of convertible preferreds) with more stable and predictable income streams that resemble interest payments on bonds. Since they typically carry fixed or floating dividends and stand ahead of common shares in the corporate capital structure, many Canadian investors see them as strategic vehicles for balance and tax-efficiency. This section will explore the critical factors you should evaluate when assessing the investment quality of preferred shares within a Canadian context.
Preferred shares (often referred to simply as “preferreds”) are a distinct class of corporate ownership that offers investors priority claim over common shareholders in two critical areas:
• Dividend payments (they generally receive dividends before common shareholders).
• Distribution of assets in the event of corporate liquidation (though still below bondholders).
Because of their unique position in the capital structure, preferred shares often trade with yield characteristics similar to bonds, while maintaining some equity-like features, particularly if they are convertible into common shares or if their payouts can fluctuate.
Below are some essential features that define preferred shares:
• Dividend Priority: Preferred shareholders are paid dividends before any dividends are paid to common shareholders.
• Fixed or Floating Dividend: Some preferred shares pay a fixed dividend yield (e.g., 5%), while others pay a floating rate tied to a benchmark such as the Government of Canada Treasury bill rate or prime rate.
• Perpetual vs. Term: Perpetual preferreds have no maturity date, whereas term-based preferreds may be retractable (redeemable by the shareholder) or callable (redeemable by the issuer).
• Ranking in Capital Structure: Preferreds are junior to corporate bonds but senior to common stock.
Many types of preferred shares exist in Canada, each with distinct risk and reward profiles. Understanding the nuances is crucial for matching the right preferred shares to an investor’s strategy and risk tolerance.
• Cumulative: If dividends are missed or cut due to the issuer’s financial difficulties, the skipped dividends accrue and must be paid in full before common shareholders can receive dividends again. This structure provides a degree of protection to preferred shareholders, as it guarantees the eventual payment of missed dividends (subject to the issuer’s viability).
• Non-Cumulative: If the issuer suspends or skips a dividend, non-cumulative preferred shareholders have no claim to missed payments. Thus, these are riskier from a dividend stability perspective.
• Convertible: These can be converted into a specified number of common shares at certain dates or under certain conditions. Convertibility can provide substantial upside if the underlying common stock appreciates significantly. However, the conversion terms must be carefully examined, including conversion ratios and exchange conditions.
• Non-Convertible: Provide no opportunity to convert into common shares, thus offering fewer avenues for capital appreciation. Their main appeal lies in stable dividend income and a generally more predictable risk profile.
• Retractable Preferreds: Give shareholders the right to “put” (sell) the shares back to the issuer at predetermined times and prices. This feature may protect the investor if interest rates rise or the share price declines.
• Callable Preferreds: Grant the issuer the right to buy back (or “call”) the shares before maturity, often at a premium to par value. Issuers typically exercise this right when interest rates fall, allowing them to refinance at lower costs.
• Perpetual Preferreds: Have no maturity date. Investors must gauge whether the dividend yield compensates for potentially indefinite interest rate risk.
While preferred shares stand ahead of common equity in the capital structure, they remain subordinate to debt obligations such as bonds. Thus, an issuer’s overall credit rating is one of the most critical metrics in determining the default risk. Canadian banks, such as RBC or TD, typically have high credit ratings, reflecting more stable dividend streams. Meanwhile, a smaller, more volatile corporation might carry a lower rating, implying higher default risk and potentially higher yields.
Agencies including DBRS Morningstar, S&P Global Ratings, and Fitch Ratings assess the creditworthiness of Canadian companies, providing letter-grade ratings. Some institutional and retail investors have guidelines or regulations requiring minimum credit ratings for portfolio purchases. Always refer to official sources like SEDAR filings, bond rating agency websites, and issuer annual reports for validation and updated data.
The reliability of preferred dividends often hinges on the issuer’s cash flow. One common measure is the dividend coverage ratio, which can be simplified as:
Some analysts focus primarily on preferred share dividends to get a more conservative view:
A strong coverage ratio suggests the issuer has sufficient income to consistently meet its dividend obligations on preferred shares. However, always read the issuer’s financial statements in detail—particularly the statement of cash flows—to confirm whether earnings translate into actual cash.
Many confine themselves to net earnings but ignore cash flows. An issuer might appear profitable, but if cash flow is constrained (due to high capital expenditures, for instance), maintaining dividend payments can become challenging. Look into:
• Operational cash flow vs. total dividends.
• Capital expenditures (CapEx) and debt service obligations.
• Trends in free cash flow over multiple quarters or years.
In Canada, dividends from eligible Canadian corporations often qualify for the dividend tax credit, reducing an investor’s effective tax rate compared to interest income. Investors in higher tax brackets may benefit substantially from this credit. Consult the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) website (https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency.html) for details on how the dividend tax credit applies in your province.
Preferred share dividends within Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) or Tax-Free Savings Accounts (TFSAs) can reduce or eliminate immediate tax liability, allowing the dividend income to compound. For instance, if you hold preferred shares of a major Canadian bank inside your TFSA, dividend income and capital gains are free from tax, potentially improving net returns.
Each province may have different surtaxes or dividend tax credits. For example, Ontario and Quebec have distinct rates. Ensure that you verify how your province’s tax structure affects the net yield.
Preferred shares typically offer higher yields than the same issuer’s bonds. This occurs because, despite the dividend priority over common shares, preferred shareholders still rank behind bondholders in a default scenario.
Preferred share prices can be more volatile than bonds because of:
• Reduced trading liquidity.
• Greater susceptibility to equity market sentiment.
• Dividend cancellations if the issuer faces financial distress (especially for non-cumulative preferreds).
Still, preferred shareholders may experience fewer price fluctuations than common shareholders due to more stable dividend income.
Fixed-rate perpetual preferreds can exhibit significant interest rate risk. When interest rates rise, the market price of these shares often falls because their fixed dividends become less attractive relative to prevailing yields.
Many Canadian issuers offer rate-reset preferred shares, where the dividend is periodically reset based on a benchmark (such as the 5-year Government of Canada bond yield) plus a stated spread. This mechanism reduces interest rate risk relative to strictly perpetual fixed-rate preferreds, though the spread and reset date remain crucial details.
Dividend rates may float with short-term benchmarks. These shares can have lower price volatility in a rising interest rate environment. However, in a declining rate environment, floating-rate dividends decrease, which might reduce the share’s appeal.
Suppose RBC (a fictional example for illustration) issues a perpetual non-cumulative preferred share with a 5% annual dividend. You want to evaluate whether this is suitable for your portfolio. Here is a step-by-step approach:
Below is a simplified process diagram for assessing a preferred share’s investment quality:
flowchart TB
A[Identify Preferred Share] --> B[Check Issuer Credit Rating and Financial Stability]
B --> C[Analyze Dividend Terms (Cumulative, Non-Cumulative, etc.)]
C --> D[Calculate Dividend Coverage & Free Cash Flow]
D --> E[Assess Tax Implications (Dividend Tax Credit, RRSP, TFSA)]
E --> F[Evaluate Yield vs. Risk]
F --> G[Determine Interest Rate Sensitivity (Fixed, Floating, Rate-Reset)]
G --> H[Make an Informed Buy/Hold/Sell Decision]
• Best Practices:
• Common Pitfalls:
• Credit Rating Agencies:
– DBRS Morningstar: https://www.dbrsmorningstar.com/
– S&P Global Ratings: https://www.spglobal.com/ratings/en/
– Fitch Ratings: https://www.fitchratings.com/
• Canadian Regulators:
– CIRO (Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization)
– CSA (Canadian Securities Administrators)
– SEDAR (System for Electronic Document Analysis and Retrieval): https://www.sedar.com/
• Taxation & Government Resources:
– Canada Revenue Agency: https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency.html
• Literature:
– “Preferred Stock Investing” by Doug K. Le Du (for a comprehensive approach to preferred share strategies).
– Annual Reports: Consult the company’s issuer pages and SEDAR for official financial statements.
• Open-Source Tools/Software:
– Many open-source financial modeling spreadsheets and Python libraries (e.g., pandas, NumPy) can be used to analyze free cash flow and dividend coverage.
Always verify data with official sources, including annual and quarterly financial reports, press releases, and regulatory updates. Remain conscious of CIRO guidelines regarding distribution of capital and maintenance of regulatory capital levels.
CSC® Vol.1 Mastery: Hardest Mock Exams & Solutions
• Dive into 6 full-length mock exams—1,500 questions in total—expertly matching the scope of CSC Exam 1.
• Experience scenario-driven case questions and in-depth solutions, surpassing standard references.
• Build confidence with step-by-step explanations designed to sharpen exam-day strategies.
CSC® Vol.2 Mastery: Hardest Mock Exams & Solutions
• Tackle 1,500 advanced questions spread across 6 rigorous mock exams (250 questions each).
• Gain real-world insight with practical tips and detailed rationales that clarify tricky concepts.
• Stay aligned with CIRO guidelines and CSI’s exam structure—this is a resource intentionally more challenging than the real exam to bolster your preparedness.
Note: While these courses are specifically crafted to align with the CSC® exams outlines, they are independently developed and not endorsed by CSI or CIRO.
By understanding how to assess preferred share investment quality—examining credit ratings, dividend coverage, share features, tax benefits, and interest rate sensitivity—investors can make more informed decisions. Whether you’re seeking stable dividend income or looking to balance an equity-heavy portfolio, preferred shares can offer an attractive blend of yield and potential growth. Always continue to refine your analysis process, stay updated on regulatory guidelines, and consider professional advice when navigating the evolving world of Canadian financial markets.