Discover the diversification potential, enhanced returns, and unique risks associated with alternative investments in Canada. Learn how hedge funds, private equity, real assets, and other specialized products can complement traditional portfolios.
Alternative investments, which can include hedge funds, private equity, real estate partnerships, infrastructure projects, and other non-traditional assets or strategies, have gained growing acceptance as legitimate portfolio diversifiers among institutional and retail investors in Canada. Unlike conventional mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that focus on equities or bonds, many alternative funds deploy advanced techniques such as short-selling, leverage, or derivatives to achieve their objectives.
In the Canadian context, alternative investments are governed by regulators such as the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) and the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA). Instruments like alternative mutual funds (sometimes referred to as “liquid alts”) are subject to National Instrument 81-102, which governs mutual fund structures but allows for more flexible investment strategies compared to traditional funds. This section explores the key benefits, risks, and suitability considerations involved in investing in alternative products.
Conventional equity and fixed-income assets often exhibit periodic correlation, particularly during times of market stress. Incorporating alternative assets or strategies that have a low or negative correlation to broader market movements can help smooth out overall returns. For example, a hedge fund specializing in merger arbitrage may generate returns based primarily on deal-specific factors rather than broad market trends. This can mitigate total portfolio volatility:
• When equity markets decline, uncorrelated alternative strategies might still generate positive returns or smaller losses.
• Investors may reduce the “drawdown risk” (peak-to-trough decline) by diversifying into alternative products.
Alternative managers often have greater flexibility in their investment mandates. They may pursue specialized areas such as:
• Distressed debt: Buying deeply discounted bonds from companies facing bankruptcy or restructuring in anticipation of a corporate turnaround or liquidation payouts.
• Real estate: Investing in properties or Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) that focus on commercial, residential, or industrial assets.
• Arbitrage strategies: Exploiting pricing discrepancies across markets, such as convertible arbitrage or merger arbitrage.
• Niche themes: Tapping into emerging trends like renewable energy, biotech, or cybersecurity through private equity vehicles.
These approaches can uncover opportunities that are less accessible to traditional mutual funds or index-tracking ETFs. For instance, a Canadian pension fund might allocate a percentage of its portfolio to infrastructure projects (e.g., toll roads, renewable power plants) to gain stable, inflation-linked cash flows and reduce dependence on public markets.
One of the main appeals of alternative investments is their potential to deliver “alpha,” or outperformance relative to a benchmark. Skilled alternative managers might identify market inefficiencies and implement sophisticated techniques (e.g., short-selling, derivatives overlays) to capitalize on them. By contrast, a typical long-only equity fund is largely exposed to market beta (the broad market’s directional risk).
• Hedge funds specializing in long/short equity can profit from both rising and falling stocks, provided their research accurately identifies overvalued and undervalued securities.
• Private equity projects can pursue hands-on operational improvements in portfolio companies, striving for returns that exceed public market equivalents.
Some alternative products focus on industries or projects with a higher growth potential but also elevated risk. Examples might include:
• Technology startups: Early-stage venture capital investments in disruptive software or biotech firms.
• Real estate development: Investing in properties requiring extensive work before reaching profitability (e.g., brownfield site redevelopment).
• niche renewable energy projects: Wind farms, solar power, and other “green” initiatives that may benefit from regulatory incentives, but could also face technological or legislative risks.
While these strategies can deliver strong returns, they also expose investors to concentrated risks such as project failure, regulatory changes, or sudden shifts in market sentiment.
Many alternative strategies involve assets or contracts that are not as easily traded as publicly listed stocks and bonds. As a result, investors may face:
• Lock-Up Periods: A hedge fund might impose a one-year lock-up, preventing redemptions within the initial year of investment.
• Redemption Gates: During times of market distress, some funds may temporarily limit redemptions to protect the fund’s liquidity.
• Early Withdrawal Penalties: Investors who redeem prematurely might incur significant fees that reduce net returns.
Alternative funds often use leverage—borrowed money or derivative contracts—to boost potential returns. While this can magnify gains, it also amplifies losses when markets move against a position. For example:
• A fund employing high leverage in energy futures might incur dramatic losses if oil prices collapse unexpectedly.
• Option-based strategies can give rise to large, sudden drawdowns if volatility spikes or underlying assets shift in the opposite direction from the manager’s forecast.
This inherent complexity underscores the importance of robust risk management and thorough due diligence.
Unlike buying a straightforward equity or bond, investing in an alternative vehicle often requires evaluating:
• Complex investment strategies (e.g., merger arbitrage, managed futures, or global macro).
• Manager track records that can be difficult to interpret due to shorter performance histories or less standardized reporting.
• Unique fee structures, such as performance fees that charge a percentage of profits above a hurdle rate.
Retail investors without specialized expertise may find it difficult to assess the true risk-reward profile of an alternative investment, increasing the chance of misallocating capital.
Although alternative mutual funds (liquid alts) are increasingly governed by frameworks such as National Instrument 81-102, privately offered funds may be subject to less rigorous regulatory oversight. Potential pitfalls include:
• Mismanagement or fraud: Some private funds have historically been implicated in scandals due to weak investor protections.
• Evolving regulations: Changes in securities or tax legislation can affect the structure, distribution, or profitability of certain alternative products.
• Jurisdictional complexity: Cross-border investments might require compliance with multiple regulatory regimes, adding administrative burdens.
Compared to publicly traded securities that disclose detailed financials and quarterly reports, alternatives often provide less frequent or more limited transparency. This can pose challenges for due diligence:
• Hedge funds may offer only quarterly or semi-annual updates, limiting insight into monthly performance fluctuations.
• Private equity funds often give minimal disclosures due to the proprietary nature of their deals.
• Illiquid projects, such as infrastructure or real estate developments, might release only high-level details on timelines and costs.
Before recommending an alternative product, advisors must ensure it aligns with a client’s risk profile, financial goals, and understanding of complex strategies. CIRO guidelines stress the importance of Know Your Client (KYC) and assessing whether the investor can tolerate the potential for significant losses, illiquidity, and short-term volatility.
Many alternative strategies require a longer holding period to offset their higher costs, slower liquidity, or potential drawdowns. For instance:
• Private equity funds typically require commitments of seven to ten years.
• Distressed debt or real estate investments may need multiple years for turnaround or renovation projects to materialize.
Investors with short-term liquidity needs may not be well-suited to certain alternative vehicles.
Incorporating alternative investments into a broader portfolio typically involves careful asset allocation and rebalancing. Some best practices include:
The following diagram illustrates how various alternative strategies can fit into a hypothetical Canadian balanced portfolio:
flowchart LR
A((Traditional Assets)) --> B[Equities<br>(Domestic & International)]
A((Traditional Assets)) --> C[Bonds<br>(Gov't & Corporate)]
B --> D((Alternatives))
C --> D((Alternatives))
D((Alternatives)) --> E[Hedge Funds<br>(Long/Short, Global Macro)]
D((Alternatives)) --> F[Private Equity<br>(Venture Capital, LBO)]
D((Alternatives)) --> G[Real Assets<br>(Real Estate, Infrastructure)]
By strategically blending alternatives with core equity and bond holdings, investors may achieve better diversification and risk-adjusted returns.
• Alpha: The excess return of an investment relative to the return of a benchmark index.
• Long/Short Strategy: An investment approach that takes long positions in undervalued securities and short positions in overvalued securities to profit from both upward and downward price movements.
• Leverage: The use of borrowed capital or derivatives to increase a position’s market exposure beyond the cash invested.
• Lock-Up Period: A contractual time frame during which investors cannot redeem or sell their shares in a fund.
• CIRO’s Regulations on Leveraged Products and Derivatives (www.cirolaw.ca)
• CSA’s Rules on Non-Traditional Funds, including National Instrument 81-102 (www.securities-administrators.ca)
• “Managing Investment Portfolios: A Dynamic Process” by the CFA Institute
• Yahoo Finance and TMX Money (https://money.tmx.com) for performance tracking and research
• Articles from the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) relating to alternative investment suitability and risk disclosure
CSC® Vol.1 Mastery: Hardest Mock Exams & Solutions
• Dive into 6 full-length mock exams—1,500 questions in total—expertly matching the scope of CSC Exam 1.
• Experience scenario-driven case questions and in-depth solutions, surpassing standard references.
• Build confidence with step-by-step explanations designed to sharpen exam-day strategies.
CSC® Vol.2 Mastery: Hardest Mock Exams & Solutions
• Tackle 1,500 advanced questions spread across 6 rigorous mock exams (250 questions each).
• Gain real-world insight with practical tips and detailed rationales that clarify tricky concepts.
• Stay aligned with CIRO guidelines and CSI’s exam structure—this is a resource intentionally more challenging than the real exam to bolster your preparedness.
Note: While these courses are specifically crafted to align with the CSC® exams outlines, they are independently developed and not endorsed by CSI or CIRO.