Explore the various types of underwriting agreements, their roles, responsibilities, and financial implications in the Canadian securities market.
In the world of finance, underwriting agreements play a crucial role in the issuance of new securities. These agreements outline the terms under which investment banks or underwriters agree to purchase and subsequently sell securities to the public. Understanding the different types of underwriting agreements is essential for anyone involved in the securities market, particularly within the Canadian context. This section will delve into the various types of underwriting agreements, detailing the roles and responsibilities involved, how underwriting fees and spreads are determined, and providing practical examples to illustrate these concepts.
Underwriting agreements are contracts between a group of investment banks or underwriters and the issuing company. These agreements specify the terms and conditions under which the underwriters will purchase securities from the issuer and sell them to the public. The primary purpose of underwriting is to ensure that the issuer raises the required capital while transferring the risk of selling the securities to the underwriters.
There are several types of underwriting agreements, each with its own set of roles, responsibilities, and financial implications. The most common types include:
In a firm commitment underwriting, the underwriter purchases the entire issue of securities from the issuer and resells them to the public. This type of agreement provides the issuer with a guarantee that the entire issue will be sold, as the underwriter assumes the risk of any unsold securities. The underwriter profits from the spread, which is the difference between the purchase price paid to the issuer and the selling price to the public.
Example: Suppose a Canadian technology company is issuing $100 million in new shares. An investment bank agrees to a firm commitment underwriting, purchasing all shares at $95 million and selling them to the public at $100 million, earning a $5 million spread.
In a best efforts underwriting, the underwriter agrees to sell as much of the issue as possible but does not guarantee the sale of the entire issue. The issuer bears the risk of any unsold securities. This type of agreement is often used for smaller or riskier issues where the underwriter is unwilling to assume the full risk.
Example: A small Canadian biotech firm is issuing $20 million in shares. An underwriter agrees to a best efforts underwriting, attempting to sell as many shares as possible but not guaranteeing the sale of the entire $20 million.
An all-or-none underwriting is a variation of the best efforts agreement. The underwriter agrees to sell the entire issue or cancel the offering if the entire issue cannot be sold. This type of agreement protects the issuer from a partial sale, which might not meet their capital needs.
Example: A Canadian renewable energy company is issuing $50 million in bonds. The underwriter agrees to an all-or-none underwriting, meaning if they cannot sell all $50 million, the offering will be canceled.
Standby underwriting is commonly used in rights offerings, where existing shareholders are given the right to purchase additional shares. The underwriter agrees to purchase any shares not subscribed to by existing shareholders, ensuring the issuer raises the desired capital.
Example: A Canadian mining company offers existing shareholders the right to purchase additional shares. The underwriter agrees to a standby underwriting, purchasing any unsubscribed shares to ensure the company raises the full amount.
The roles and responsibilities in underwriting agreements vary depending on the type of agreement. However, some common roles include:
Underwriting fees and spreads are critical components of underwriting agreements. The underwriting fee is the compensation received by underwriters for their services, while the spread is the difference between the price paid to the issuer and the price at which the securities are sold to the public.
Underwriting fees are typically a percentage of the total issue size and vary based on the complexity and risk of the offering. In Canada, underwriting fees can range from 3% to 7% of the total issue size, depending on factors such as the issuer’s creditworthiness and market conditions.
The spread compensates the underwriter for the risk of holding and selling the securities. It is determined by the difference between the purchase price from the issuer and the selling price to the public. The spread can vary based on market conditions, the issuer’s reputation, and the demand for the securities.
Consider a scenario where a major Canadian bank, such as RBC, is underwriting a $500 million bond issue for a Canadian utility company. RBC agrees to a firm commitment underwriting, purchasing the bonds at $490 million and selling them to the public at $500 million, earning a $10 million spread. The underwriting fee is set at 5%, amounting to $25 million. This example illustrates how underwriting agreements function in practice, highlighting the roles, responsibilities, and financial implications involved.
To enhance understanding, let’s visualize the flow of a firm commitment underwriting agreement:
graph TD;
A[Issuer] -->|Sells Securities| B[Underwriter];
B -->|Sells Securities| C[Public Investors];
B -->|Receives Underwriting Fee & Spread| A;
Best Practices:
Common Pitfalls:
Understanding the different types of underwriting agreements is essential for anyone involved in the securities market. Each type of agreement has its own set of roles, responsibilities, and financial implications. By comprehending these agreements, finance professionals can make informed decisions and effectively manage the risks associated with securities offerings.
Practice 10 Essential CSC Exam Questions to Master Your Certification